Football · The Panna Project
Football
The week in football: who mattered most, how the title races stand, and what we expect next. Ratings and forecasts from Panna, our open-source player model.
Every football page
How Panna works
Traditional football stats tell you what a player did. Panna ratings try to answer a harder question: how much did it actually matter?
The core idea is plus-minus: when a player is on the pitch, does their team create more and concede less than expected? Raw plus-minus is noisy (your numbers look great if you play alongside Messi), so the model controls for the quality of every other player on the field. Think of it as isolating your contribution from everyone else’s.
For players without enough minutes to get a reliable plus-minus estimate, the model falls back on box-score stats like key passes, interceptions and progressive carries, which tend to predict plus-minus well. The final Panna rating blends both signals, leaning more on the box score for bit-part players and more on plus-minus for regulars.
The rating splits into offense and defense. Positive offense means you’re helping create goals. Positive defense means you’re preventing them. Add them together and you get the overall picture.